On November 18, 2026, the Tennessee Court of Appeals held that a woman hurt in a Hamblen County wreck forfeited her underinsured motorist claim against her own insurance company. One piece of paper did it. Before she ever filed suit, she took the other driver’s $25,000 policy limits and signed a release, and the steps Tennessee law sets out for doing that safely were never followed. Her lawsuit asked her own carrier for $373,550. The court said it owed her nothing.
The case is Moore v. Helton. If an adjuster has a release sitting on your kitchen table right now, read this before you sign it. Better yet, text me a picture of it at (423) 765-1215.
What happened in Moore v. Helton
The wreck was on March 30, 2019, in Hamblen County, the county around Morristown. Stacy Moore said a driver in a GMC Sierra pulled into her path and hit her, and that her injuries were continuing or permanent. The other driver had a $25,000 liability policy. Ms. Moore had uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage, usually called UM, with Tennessee Farmers. That is the coverage on your own policy that is supposed to pick up where a cheap policy runs out.
On March 23, 2020, Ms. Moore and her husband signed a full release of the other driver in exchange for the $25,000. It released every claim from the wreck. It also said the driver did not admit any liability. Keep that last line in mind.
She later sued the driver and Farmers in Hamblen County Circuit Court. Farmers moved for summary judgment. Judge William E. Phillips, II, granted it in April 2025, and the Court of Appeals affirmed.
Why her own insurance company walked away
When your UM carrier pays you, the law lets it step into your shoes and go after the driver who caused the wreck. Lawyers call that subrogation. Tennessee’s UM statute gives the carrier that right, and Ms. Moore’s policy said the same thing. Her Farmers policy also said there was no UM coverage if she settled her claim without the company’s written consent.
A full release ends every claim you have against the driver. Once it is signed, your UM carrier has nothing left to pursue against that driver. The Court of Appeals relied on earlier Tennessee cases holding that when an insured releases the at-fault driver and destroys the carrier’s subrogation rights, the insured forfeits any right to recover from the carrier. Ms. Moore did exactly that, so her UM claim was gone.
She argued Farmers had to prove the release actually hurt it. The Tennessee Supreme Court has held that late notice of a wreck does not let an insurer off the hook unless the delay prejudiced it. The Court of Appeals said that rule came from reading an insurance policy. This case turned on a statute that spells out what has to happen before you sign, and she did not follow it. The court rejected her prejudice argument.
She also tried a straight breach of contract claim. That failed too. A UM carrier generally does not owe you anything until the other driver is found legally at fault, and her release said the driver admitted no liability. The driver’s fault was never established, so the court held Farmers had no contract duty to pay.
The part that bothers me
Ms. Moore and her husband both signed affidavits saying they talked several times with a Farmers representative and with Farmers’ lawyer about the settlement and about Farmers’ subrogation rights. They said Farmers never objected and never told them the settlement would hurt its interests. They said they asked for a copy of their own policy more than once and were turned down.
None of it mattered. The statute calls for written notices sent a certain way, and the court found no evidence they were ever sent. If what the Moores said is true, Farmers knew about the settlement talks, never objected and still won. The law put the burden on her. It will put it on you too.
Adjusters for the at-fault driver want the file closed. You will hear something like “Sign this and we can get the check out this week.” Under the statute, the other driver’s insurance company is the one that has to send your UM carrier written notice of the offer. Do not assume it did.
How Tennessee lets you take the limits and keep your UM claim
The law does give you a safe way to take the other driver’s money and still go after your own coverage. It is in Tennessee Code section 56-7-1206, and the court quoted the key parts of it. Here is the short version.
- The other driver’s insurance company has to offer the limits of all liability policies covering the driver, and that total has to be less than your UM coverage.
- If asked, you or your lawyer give the liability insurer your UM carrier’s name and address, your policy number and your UM limits.
- The liability insurer sends your UM carrier written notice of the offer and confirms the driver will cooperate in arbitration if your carrier waives subrogation.
- You send your UM carrier written notice that you intend to accept the offer and that you agree to binding arbitration of your UM claim.
- Those notices go by certified mail, return receipt requested, or some other way that gives written proof they were received.
- Your UM carrier then has 30 days after it gets both notices to consent, agree to arbitration and waive subrogation. Only after you get your carrier’s written notice that it consents do you sign the release and take the check.
Your carrier has one other choice. Within those same 30 days it can turn down arbitration and keep its right to go after the driver by paying you the full amount of the offer itself. If you accept that payment, it does not release the driver, and it does not stop you from going after more under your UM coverage.
In an earlier case, the Court of Appeals held that the liability insurer’s written notice is mandatory. Until it is given, your UM carrier does not have to make either choice. So you cannot just send your own letter and assume you are covered.
The second trap in this case
The trial judge had another reason for ruling against Ms. Moore. She filed her first lawsuit within the one-year deadline. The judge found that the other driver was never served in that case, and that after Ms. Moore dismissed and refiled, the driver was never served in the second case either. He found the summonses had gone unserved for more than a year in both suits, so the deadline had run against the driver. Ms. Moore disputed the finding that the driver was never served. The judge reasoned that with no live claim against the driver, she had no claim against Farmers. The Court of Appeals did not decide that issue because the release had already ended the case.
Under Rule 3 of the Tennessee Rules of Civil Procedure, filing on time is only half of it. If a summons is not issued within 90 days, or not served within 90 days after it is issued, you lose the benefit of your filing date unless new process is issued within one year of the previous one. A case filed on time can still end up too late.
Who you hire matters here
The rules in this case come from three different places, and the deadlines run whether you know about them or not. Before you hire anyone, ask how many uninsured and underinsured claims that lawyer has handled and how they make sure your UM carrier gets proper written notice before you sign a thing.
Before a client of mine signs anything, I want every policy that might pay on the table. That means the at-fault driver’s policy, your policy, other policies in your household and the policy on the car you were riding in. You can read more about how that works on my uninsured and underinsured driver page and my page on policy limits offers.
Here is what it looks like when it goes right. Same $25,000 limit as the Moore case. This is from my results page, word for word.
My client was T-boned on Old Stage Road in Gray. She suffered a compression fracture in her back and later needed spine surgery. The other driver carried only $25,000 in coverage, the kind of number that makes most people think the case is over.
It was not. I fought her own insurance company over her underinsured motorist coverage, and it paid $410,000 on top of the other driver’s $25,000 limit. With a $5,000 medical payments waiver, the total value came to $440,000.
Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
If you were hurt in a wreck around Morristown, Kingsport, Johnson City or anywhere in East Tennessee and the other driver’s insurance company has offered its limits, do not sign yet. Text me a picture of the offer and the release at (423) 765-1215, or call. The consultation is free, and there is no fee unless we win. You can hire me without leaving home.
Hurt in a wreck? Don't wait. Call Bates.
Talk to the lawyer whose name is on the door. Free consultation, no fee unless we win.
Call (423) 765-1215